A client wants links to their office cleaning service page. Your supplier’s shortlist has two kinds of site on it: a small facilities management blog with modest metrics, and a big general business magazine with a much higher DR. Which one should the budget go on? Most agencies face this choice on every order, and the answer is rarely “always the niche site” or “always the bigger site”.
This guide is for agencies and consultants who buy guest posts for clients. It explains what “niche-relevant” and “general” really mean, what Google has and hasn’t said about relevance, a simple scoring sheet you can use on any shortlist, when a general site is a sensible buy, which general sites to avoid, and how to split a client budget between the two. A worked example (hypothetical) shows the whole process.
The short answer
For a page you need to rank, put most of the budget on placements where the article itself is about the client’s subject, on a site whose readers overlap with the client’s customers. Those are usually niche or close-neighbour sites. A general site is a reasonable buy when the specific article is genuinely on topic, the site has real readers and editorial standards, and the link is natural in context. What you should never buy is a site that publishes anything for anyone: that isn’t a “general” site, it’s a link seller.
Relevance is judged at more than one level. A niche site that will publish any guest post on any subject is less relevant in practice than a well-run general site running one properly written article about your client’s topic. So score the site, the page and the link, not just the site’s category.
What “niche-relevant” and “general” actually mean
The labels get used loosely on supplier lists, so it helps to agree definitions before comparing prices:
- Pure-niche site: covers one subject in depth, for example a facilities management blog, a UK employment law journal or a garden design magazine. Its traffic comes from searches in that subject.
- Close-neighbour site: covers a related subject with the same audience. For a cleaning company, that might be an office management, property management or workplace health site.
- General site: covers many subjects for a broad audience, such as a business magazine, a regional news site or a lifestyle publication. It has real sections, real authors and its own readership.
- “Multi-niche” link seller: publishes paid articles on any subject, often in the same week: loans, casinos, CBD, software and home improvement side by side. It is often described as “general”, but it is a different thing entirely, and it’s on the list of sites we reject in our link quality policy.
Most real shortlists contain all four. The useful question is not “niche or general?” but “how relevant is this particular placement, and is the site a real publication?”
What Google says about relevance (and what it doesn’t)
Google doesn’t publish a relevance score for links, and it doesn’t say that a niche link is worth a fixed multiple of a general one. Any figure like that you read online is someone’s estimate, not Google’s. What Google does say is useful, though.
- Links from prominent sites on a subject are a quality signal. Google’s own explanation of ranking says one factor used to determine quality is “understanding if other prominent websites link or refer to the content”, and that this “is generally a good sign that the information is trustworthy” (Google: How Search works, ranking results).
- Paid links meant to pass ranking credit are link spam. Google’s spam policies list “advertorials or native advertising where payment is received for articles that include links that pass ranking credit, or links with optimized anchor text in articles, guest posts, or press releases distributed on other sites” as examples (Google Search Central: spam policies). The same page says buying and selling links isn’t a violation when the links are qualified with
rel="nofollow"orrel="sponsored". - Off-topic writing is a warning sign. Google’s 2017 reminder about large-scale guest post campaigns lists, among the factors that “when taken to an extreme” can indicate a violation, “using or hiring article writers that aren’t knowledgeable about the topics they’re writing on” and publishing the same or similar content across many sites (Google Search Central Blog: links in large-scale article campaigns).
- Big sites hosting unrelated third-party content can be actioned. Google’s site reputation policy covers third-party content “published on a host site mainly because of that host’s already-established ranking signals”. Its examples include an educational site hosting sponsored payday loan reviews and a medical site hosting a third-party “best casinos” page. The policy also says that editorial work and advertorials written for the publication’s own readers are not in breach.
Read together, these point one way. Relevance isn’t a box to tick for appearances. A link is more likely to be the kind of reference Google describes when it sits in content written for that site’s readers by someone who knows the subject. A high-authority site that hosts unrelated paid content is not a safe shortcut, however good its metrics look.
One honest caveat: the rel attribute doesn’t change with relevance. Google asks for paid placements to be marked sponsored (see Qualify your outbound links), whether the site is niche or general. Our guide to anchor text strategy covers the anchor side of the same rules.
Relevance works at four levels
Most buyers check only the first level. Check all four:
| Level | What to check | Quick test | Red flag |
|---|---|---|---|
| Site | What the site covers overall and where its traffic comes from | Look at its top pages in Ahrefs or Semrush: do they rank for terms in its own subject? | Top pages rank for unrelated or foreign-language terms |
| Page | What the specific article (or proposed topic) is about | Would the article make sense to the site’s readers without your link? | A generic “10 tips” article with the link bolted on |
| Link | The anchor and the sentence around it | Does the link help the reader at that point in the text? | An exact-match commercial anchor, or several client links in one post |
| Audience | Who reads the site, and where they are | Would your client’s buyers plausibly read this? For UK-only clients, is the audience UK-based? | Traffic mostly from countries your client doesn’t serve |
The page and link levels are where most of the value is won or lost. That is also why a niche site isn’t automatically the better buy: if it will run any article for a fee, the page itself may have nothing to do with the site’s subject. Our guide to vetting a guest post site covers the wider checks, and DR vs traffic explains why neither metric alone tells you much.
A relevance scoring sheet for any shortlist
When a supplier sends 20 domains, a consistent score stops the decision coming down to whichever site has the biggest DR. This is our own working sheet, not a Google metric. Score each placement 0 to 2 on five criteria:
| Criterion | 2 points | 1 point | 0 points |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Site topic | Same subject as the client | Close neighbour, or a general site with a real section on the subject | Unrelated, or publishes anything |
| 2. Page topic | The article is about the client’s subject | A related subject where the link is a natural reference | The link has no connection to the article |
| 3. Link context | Branded, URL or descriptive anchor that fits the sentence | Generic but acceptable (“this guide”) | Keyword-stuffed anchor, or several commercial links |
| 4. Audience | Readers include the client’s buyers, in the client’s market | Partial overlap | No overlap |
| 5. Editorial standards | Real authors, recent posts on its own topics, traffic from its own subject | Mixed signals worth a closer look | A “sponsored” section full of unrelated paid posts |
How we read the totals:
- 8 to 10: a strong fit. Use these placements for the client’s most important pages.
- 5 to 7: acceptable for supporting pages, guides or branded links, provided nothing scored 0.
- 0 to 4: reject, or ask the supplier for a different article angle and score it again.
- Any 0 on editorial standards: reject, whatever the total. A good score elsewhere can’t fix a site that sells links on any subject.
Criteria 2 and 3 depend on the article, so for a guest post you are scoring the agreed topic and anchor, not just the domain. For a niche edit you can score the exact page before you buy, because it already exists.
When a niche site is worth paying more for
Pure-niche sites often cost more than general sites with similar metrics. Our own pricing page says so: prices vary by site, and pure-niche sites can cost more than general sites. The usual reasons are simple: there are fewer of them, they turn down more pitches, and their editors expect articles that their specialist readers will actually find useful. Paying that premium makes sense when:
- The target is a money page. A service, product or category page competing for commercial terms benefits most from links in content about the same subject.
- The client is in a specialist or regulated field. For legal, financial or health clients, a link from an unrelated site looks odd to readers, and off-topic content is harder to write accurately. Our guide to link building for SaaS, eCommerce and legal sites covers what “relevant” means in each.
- Referral visitors matter. A smaller niche audience will usually send fewer clicks than a big general site, but the people who do click are much closer to buying.
- The client is local or trade-focused. Trade bodies, regional business sites and industry publications carry signals a national lifestyle site can’t. See our guide to local link building in the UK.
When a general site is the right buy
General sites have a real place in a healthy plan. They make sense when:
- The article is relevant even if the site is broad. A business magazine article about running a safe, clean office is relevant to a commercial cleaner at page level, even though the magazine covers everything from tax to travel.
- The link is a brand or homepage mention. Company profiles, founder pieces and broad “how to choose a supplier” articles naturally point to the homepage with a branded anchor.
- The niche is too narrow to supply enough sites. Some B2B niches have only a handful of credible publications. Repeating links from the same few sites month after month is less useful than adding relevant articles on well-run general sites.
- The client’s audience is the general public. For consumer products and services, general lifestyle, home and family sites may be where the buyers actually are.
In each case the conditions are the same: a real publication, an article written for its readers, and a link that fits the sentence. If any of those is missing, the lower price isn’t a saving.
General sites to avoid
Some sites look like general publications but behave like link sellers. Skip them, whatever their DR:
- “Publish anything” sites. Scroll the latest posts. If casino reviews, loan offers, CBD and software round-ups sit side by side in the same week, the site is selling links, not serving readers.
- Sponsored sections that don’t match the site. A news or education site with a “partner content” area full of unrelated paid articles is the pattern Google’s site reputation policy describes. Those pages can lose visibility, and your client’s link goes with them.
- Traffic from the wrong place. A high traffic figure driven by one viral post, coupon terms or a country your client doesn’t serve tells you little about real readership.
- Sites where you can’t see the rest of the page. If a supplier won’t tell you the domain before you pay, you can’t judge relevance at any level, and you can’t explain the link to a client. Watch for the network footprints in our guide on how to spot a PBN.
A quick check on any domain: run the URL of a recent guest post through our free link analyzer to see how many outbound links it carries and with which rel values, and check the domain’s history with the domain age checker.
How to split a client budget between niche and general sites
There is no ratio from Google, and we don’t use a fixed one. Instead, plan by target page:
- List the pages that need links and what each one is for: commercial page, supporting guide or brand.
- Give commercial pages the highest-scoring placements, usually niche or close-neighbour sites with an 8 to 10 score.
- Use general sites for supporting guides and brand links, but only placements scoring 5 or more, with no zero on editorial standards.
- Check the anchor mix across the whole month, so the niche placements don’t all carry the same commercial phrase.
- Review after a few months using the target pages’ impressions and rankings in Search Console, not the number of links. Our guide on how many backlinks per month a site needs covers setting the volume.
Worked example (hypothetical)
The following is an illustration, not a real client. A UK agency has a commercial cleaning client in Manchester with a budget for six guest posts this month. The pages that need links are the office cleaning service page, a guide to office cleaning schedules, and the homepage. The supplier’s shortlist is scored with the sheet above:
| Placement | Score | Decision | Target page and anchor | List price (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Facilities management blog, DR 34, article on outsourcing cleaning contracts | 9 | Buy | Office cleaning service page, descriptive anchor | $125 (Standard) |
| Property management site, DR 31, article on keeping shared offices compliant | 8 | Buy | Office cleaning service page, branded anchor | $125 (Standard) |
| Workplace health blog, DR 38, article on reducing sick days | 8 | Buy | Cleaning schedules guide, descriptive anchor | $125 (Standard) |
| UK business magazine, DR 56, article on running a small office | 7 | Buy | Cleaning schedules guide, URL anchor | $319 (Premium) |
| Regional business news site, DR 24, article on Manchester SME costs | 6 | Buy | Homepage, branded anchor | $99 (Starter) |
| Lifestyle blog, DR 27, article on spring cleaning at home | 5 | Buy | Homepage, branded anchor | $99 (Starter) |
| “General news” site, DR 61, sponsored section with casino and loan posts | Rejected (0 on editorial standards) | Skip | – | – |
At our list prices, the six accepted placements come to $892 before any niche premium a specific site might add. That is under the 10-link threshold for our volume discount. Three of the six placements ($375 of the budget) go to niche and close-neighbour sites aimed at the page that sells and its guide, and the most expensive link is a general site, chosen because its article is relevant, not because of its DR. The site with the highest DR on the list is the one that gets rejected.
Note the lifestyle blog: it scores only 5 (one point on each criterion), mainly because its readers are homeowners rather than office managers. It’s acceptable for a branded homepage link, but it would be a poor choice for the commercial page.
Questions to ask your supplier about relevance
- Will I see every domain before anything is published, and can I reject any?
- Where does each site’s organic traffic come from: its own subject, or unrelated terms?
- What topic will the article cover, and who writes it?
- Can I choose the target page and anchor, and will the editor be able to adjust the wording?
- Does the site publish paid posts on unrelated subjects? Is there a separate sponsored section?
- Do pure-niche sites cost more, and how is the price for each site worked out?
- What happens if a link is removed, and for how long?
A supplier who can’t answer the first two questions can’t give you a meaningful relevance score either.
How Linkvista handles relevance
Every site on our lists is checked by hand against our link quality policy: at least 500 monthly organic visits, traffic from genuine keywords in the site’s own subject, real authors and a sensible ratio of outbound links. We don’t use PBNs, link farms or “write for us” sites that publish on any topic. You see and approve every domain before anything is published, so you can score each one yourself.
Guest posts include a standard 1,000-word article written for the host site’s readers. Longer articles are charged extra per additional 500 words, or you can supply your own. Links go live within 48 to 72 hours of domain approval, and if a link is removed within 12 months we replace it free. Prices vary by site, as pure-niche sites can cost more than general sites, so tell us the client’s niche and target pages when you ask for a quote.
Frequently asked questions
Are niche-relevant backlinks better than general ones?
For ranking a specific page, links in content about the same subject are usually the better buy. Google doesn’t publish a relevance score, but it says links from prominent sites on a subject are a sign of trustworthy content. A relevant article on a well-run general site can still be a good link, so judge the page and the link as well as the site.
Is a guest post on a general news site worth buying?
It can be, if the article is genuinely about your client’s topic, the site has real readers and the link fits the text. Avoid news or education sites whose sponsored sections are full of unrelated paid content, because Google’s site reputation policy targets that pattern.
How do I check whether a guest post site is relevant to my client?
Check four levels: what the site covers and where its traffic comes from, what the article is about, whether the anchor and sentence fit naturally, and whether the readers overlap with the client’s customers. Scoring each placement 0 to 2 on a few criteria makes a shortlist easier to compare.
Why do niche sites cost more for guest posts?
There are fewer of them, they turn down more pitches, and their editors expect articles their specialist readers will find useful. Linkvista’s prices vary by site, and pure-niche sites can cost more than general sites with similar metrics.
What percentage of backlinks should be niche relevant?
Google doesn’t give a ratio, and we don’t use a fixed one. Plan by target page instead: put the most relevant placements on the client’s commercial pages, use relevant articles on good general sites for guides and brand links, and reject anything from sites that publish on any topic.
Can a general site be relevant at page level?
Yes. A business magazine article about running a safe office is relevant to a commercial cleaning company, even though the magazine covers many subjects. Page-level relevance only counts if the site is a real publication with its own readers, not a site that publishes anything for a fee.
Get relevant guest posts for your clients
We place guest posts and niche edits on relevant sites with real organic traffic, and you approve every domain first. Guest posts start at $99 (DR 20–29) and go up to $489 (DR 70+) per link in USD, each with a standard 1,000-word article. Niche edits start at $85. Agencies ordering 10+ links a month save 10%, and 25+ links save 15%. Links go live within 48–72 hours of approval, reports are unbranded, and removed links are replaced free within 12 months.
See our link building services, including guest posting and niche edits, compare tiers on our pricing page, try our free SEO tools, or contact us with your client’s niche and target pages for a relevant domain shortlist.

Leave a Reply