A client’s report says a guest post went live in March. In August, a backlink tool flags the link as lost. Has the publisher removed it, or has the tool got it wrong? And who owes whom what? Most agencies that buy links will face this sooner or later, because the publisher, not the buyer, controls the page.
This guide is for agencies that buy or resell guest posts and niche edits. It covers how to confirm a link is really gone, how to work out what changed, what to put in an evidence pack, how to claim under your supplier’s terms, and how to explain it to a client without making it worse. Our own replacement terms appear near the end. Everything else applies whoever you buy from.
First, check the link is really gone
Many “lost link” alerts are not removals. Backlink tools re-crawl pages on their own schedule, and they report a link as lost for reasons that have nothing to do with the link itself. Ahrefs’ help centre lists separate “link lost” reasons, including the linking page returning a crawl error, redirecting, becoming noindex or naming a different canonical, as well as the link actually being removed (Ahrefs Help Center, “Understanding ‘link lost’ reasons”).
Google Search Console is not a live check either. Google’s help page for the Links report says it “includes links that Google has found over time. These links may have since been removed”, and that it doesn’t show whether a link is nofollow (Search Console Help: Links report). A link can still appear there after it has gone, and can be missing while it is still live.
So before anyone emails a publisher, open the page yourself:
- Load the page in a private window and note the HTTP status. A 200 means the page exists. A 404 or 410 means it’s gone. A 301 or 302 means it has moved, so follow it with our free redirect checker and see where it lands.
- Search the raw HTML, not just the visible page. View the page source and search for your client’s domain. Text that still mentions the brand isn’t a link unless it sits inside an
<a href>tag. - Compare the href with what was agreed: the same page, protocol and trailing slash. A link that now points at the homepage, or at a different client page, has been changed rather than removed.
- Read the rel attribute and record the literal value. Our free link analyzer lists every link on a page with its rel values.
- Check the page-level signals: a robots meta tag or an X-Robots-Tag HTTP header, and the canonical tag (more on these below).
- Check again a few days later before you escalate. Sites go down, caches serve old versions, and a temporary error is not a removal.
If the link is there, with the agreed target and attribute, on a page that returns 200 and is indexable, it is a false alarm. Note the date of your check in the client’s link log and move on.
What changed? Diagnose the cause
When the link really has changed, the cause decides what you can reasonably ask for. Here are the usual cases:
| What you see | Likely cause | How to confirm | Usual next step |
|---|---|---|---|
| Page returns 404 or 410 | Article deleted, section retired or lost in a site rebuild | Status code; the site’s sitemap or archive no longer lists it | Ask the supplier whether it can be restored; otherwise claim a replacement |
| Page redirects elsewhere | URL change, migration or merged content | Follow the redirect; check the final page for your link | If the link survived on the new URL, update your records. If not, report it |
| Page is live, link gone | Editor clean-up, content refresh or a new outbound-link policy | Search the source for the domain; compare with your saved copy | Report with evidence; ask for restoration or replacement |
| Link points to a different URL | Edited by mistake, or repointed by the publisher | Compare the href with the approved target | Ask for the agreed target to be restored |
| rel changed to nofollow, sponsored or ugc | Publisher policy change or sitewide plugin setting | Read the rel value in the source | Record it, check your terms, raise it with the supplier (see below) |
| Page now noindex, or blocked | SEO plugin change, staging setting or a site-wide robots change | Robots meta tag, X-Robots-Tag header, robots.txt | Report it; it may be an accident the publisher will want to fix |
| Canonical points to another URL | Duplicate handling or a template change | Read the canonical tag; check whether that URL carries your link | Record it; report if the canonical page doesn’t carry the link |
| Whole site gone or deindexed | Domain expired, business closed or site penalised | Domain doesn’t resolve, or site: search returns nothing | Claim a replacement if in the window; there is nothing to restore |
| Link is fine but the target page 404s | Your client deleted or moved their page | Load the target URL | Your side to fix: 301 the old URL to the closest live page |
The last row is worth checking first. Agencies sometimes chase a publisher for a “broken” link that broke because the client’s own site migration changed the URL. No publisher or supplier is responsible for that, and a redirect on the client’s site fixes it.
Page-level signals that can switch a link off
A link tag can look perfect while the page around it tells Google otherwise. Google’s documentation for the robots meta tag defines nofollow as “Do not follow the links on this page”, none as equivalent to noindex plus nofollow, and says the same rules can be sent in an X-Robots-Tag HTTP header (Google Search Central: robots meta tag and X-Robots-Tag). It also notes that if robots.txt blocks a page from crawling, those rules won’t be found at all.
To check the header without special tools, run curl -sI followed by the page URL in a terminal and look for an X-Robots-Tag line. For the meta tag, search the page source for name="robots" and name="googlebot".
When the rel attribute changes
Google says regular links need no rel attribute, and that links marked sponsored, ugc or nofollow “will generally not be followed”. It also asks for advertisements and paid placements to be marked rel="sponsored" (Google Search Central: qualify your outbound links).
That puts a changed attribute in a different category from a removed link. The link still exists and can still send visitors. It simply isn’t the placement that was described when the order was approved. Two points follow:
- Don’t pressure an editor to strip a sponsored attribute. Google asks publishers to mark paid placements that way. If your terms promised a particular attribute, raise it with your supplier under those terms instead.
- Be honest with the client. Paid link building always carries this risk, which is why it belongs in your proposal before the first order. Our guide to reselling link building covers how to set that expectation.
Build an evidence pack before you complain
A short, factual report gets fixed faster than an angry one. Before contacting anyone, collect:
- The live URL as reported, the date it went live and the order or invoice reference.
- What was agreed: target URL, anchor text and link attribute, ideally from the original live report.
- What you see now: HTTP status, the relevant line of HTML (or its absence) and any robots or canonical change.
- A dated screenshot showing the address bar and the paragraph where the link was.
- The dates of both checks, a few days apart, so you are reporting a settled state rather than an outage.
A saved copy of the page from the day it went live makes all of this much easier, because you can show exactly which paragraph changed. That is one reason to archive the page (a PDF or saved HTML is enough) when the link is first reported.
Who to contact, and what to ask for
If you bought the placement through a supplier, go to the supplier first. They hold the relationship with the publisher, and they are the one who made you a promise. Contacting the editor directly can cut across that relationship and, if you resell links under your own brand, can expose the arrangement your client doesn’t need to see.
Then match your request to the facts and to the terms you bought under:
| Situation | Reasonable request | Check in your terms |
|---|---|---|
| Page live, link removed or repointed | Restore the link as agreed | How long placements are guaranteed, and from what date |
| Page deleted, or site gone | A replacement on a comparable site | Whether a replacement or a refund is the remedy, and how “comparable” is judged |
| Attribute changed from the one agreed | Restore, or replace if the terms cover alterations | Whether “altered” placements are covered, not only removed ones |
| Page noindexed or blocked | Ask the publisher, via the supplier, whether it was intended | Whether indexability is part of the guarantee |
| Outside the guarantee window | A goodwill request, nothing more | The end date of the window |
The window matters most. Most guarantees run from the date the link went live, not from your order date or the date you noticed the problem. If you only check links when a client asks, a removal in month 10 might not be spotted until after the window has closed.
How to tell the client
Tell the client before they find it themselves, and lead with what you are doing about it. A short message is enough:
- What happened, in one sentence (for example, “the publisher has deleted the article that carried your link from [site]”).
- When you found it, and that you have confirmed it with two checks.
- What you have asked for, and when you expect an answer.
- What it means for the campaign: one link out of the programme, not a penalty or a ranking crisis.
Don’t speculate about ranking effects you can’t measure, and don’t promise a replacement your supplier hasn’t confirmed. If you report under your own brand, log the change in your next report so the history is visible. Our guide to white label SEO reports shows how to lay that out.
A hypothetical example
This example is invented to show the process. It isn’t a real client or publisher. An agency’s monthly check finds that a guest post placed five months earlier now has rel="sponsored" on the client link. The page still returns 200, the link points to the agreed page, and the publisher has applied the attribute to every outbound link in its sponsored articles. The agency records the change with a screenshot and the HTML line, checks again four days later, and reports it to the supplier with the original live report attached. Because the agency’s terms cover placements that are altered within the guarantee window, it asks for a replacement on a comparable site rather than asking the publisher to remove the attribute. In the next report it tells the client: one link changed attribute, a replacement has been requested, and nothing else in the programme is affected.
Prevent surprises: a simple monitoring routine
You can’t stop publishers editing their sites, but you can make sure you hear about it while the guarantee still applies. A spreadsheet is enough. Keep one row per link with these columns:
| Column | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Live URL and target URL | What you check, and what it should point to |
| Anchor text and agreed rel | The baseline for spotting an edit |
| Date live and guarantee end date | Tells you whether a claim is still possible |
| Supplier and order reference | Who to contact, and what to quote |
| Last check date, status and rel found | Proof of when it was last fine |
| Saved copy (link to PDF or HTML) | Evidence of the original paragraph |
How often to check is your call. Monthly is a sensible default for most programmes, and checking again just before a guarantee ends gives you one last chance to claim. Our free SEO tools, including the link analyzer and redirect checker, help with the link and redirect checks without a subscription.
The best prevention happens before the order. Links on sites with a real audience and genuine editorial standards tend to be more stable than links on sites that exist to sell placements. Our guides on how to vet a guest post site before buying and how to spot a PBN cover what to check. For niche edits, where the link goes into an existing article, also read what niche edits are and how they work, because older pages are more likely to be refreshed.
What not to do
- Don’t disavow by reflex. A removed link no longer points at the site, and a qualified link is already marked as one Google should generally not follow. Disavowing is meant for spammy or manipulative links, not for links you paid for that changed.
- Don’t panic-buy replacements before you know the cause. If the client’s own page broke, a redirect fixes it for free.
- Don’t contact the editor in anger or behind your supplier’s back. Most changes come from routine edits, not bad faith.
- Don’t change the date or the record. Keep the original live date in your log; it decides the guarantee window.
How Linkvista handles removed and changed links
Our published terms state that confirmed dofollow placements are guaranteed to stay live and intact for a minimum of 12 months after publication, and that if a host publication removes or alters a placement in that time, we replace it on a comparable domain at no additional fee. Links are not guaranteed after 12 months. You can read the wording in our terms of service and on our pricing page.
- You approve every domain before anything is placed, and every site is checked by hand against our link quality policy, including at least 500 monthly organic visits. We never use PBNs.
- Each order ends with an unbranded live report, so you have the live URL, target and anchor on record from day one.
- Links go live within 48–72 hours of domain approval. Guest posts include a standard 1,000-word article, with longer articles charged extra per additional 500 words, or you can supply your own article.
- To report a problem, send us the live URL, what you expected and what you see now, and we’ll check it against the original order.
Frequently asked questions
Why has my guest post link disappeared?
The usual reasons are an editor removing or rewriting the paragraph, the article being deleted or moved during a site update, a new policy on outbound links, or the whole site going offline. Sometimes nothing has changed and a backlink tool simply failed to crawl the page, so check the live page yourself before acting.
Is a link changed to nofollow or sponsored the same as a removed link?
No. The link is still on the page and can still send visitors, but Google says links marked nofollow, sponsored or ugc will generally not be followed. Whether it counts as a breach depends on what your terms promised. Google asks for paid placements to be marked sponsored, so raise it with your supplier rather than pressuring the editor.
How do I check if a backlink is still live?
Open the linking page in a private window, confirm it returns a 200 status, search the page source for your domain, and check that the link points to the agreed URL with the agreed rel attribute. Also check for a robots meta tag or X-Robots-Tag header with noindex or nofollow. Repeat the check a few days later before reporting a problem.
Does Google Search Console show when a backlink is removed?
Not reliably. Google says the Links report includes links found over time that may since have been removed, and that it doesn’t show whether a link is nofollow. Use it to spot linking sites, then check the live page for the current state.
Can I get a replacement or refund if a guest post link is removed?
That depends entirely on the terms you bought under, so check the remedy, the length of the guarantee and the date it starts. Linkvista replaces confirmed dofollow placements that are removed or altered within 12 months of publication on a comparable domain at no extra fee. There is no guarantee after 12 months.
Should I disavow a link that has been removed or made nofollow?
There is normally no reason to. A removed link no longer points at the site, and a nofollow or sponsored link is already marked as one Google should generally not follow. Disavowing is meant for spammy or manipulative links you can’t get removed.
Buy links with the guarantee in writing
We place guest posts and niche edits on relevant sites with real organic traffic, and you approve every domain first. Guest posts start at $99 (DR 20–29) and go up to $489 (DR 70+) per link in USD, each with a standard 1,000-word article. Niche edits start at $85. Agencies ordering 10+ links a month save 10%, and 25+ links save 15%. Links go live within 48–72 hours of approval, reports are unbranded, and removed or altered links are replaced free within 12 months.
See our link building services, including guest posting and niche edits, compare tiers on our pricing page, try our free SEO tools, or contact us with your target pages for a domain shortlist.

Leave a Reply